New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Clear land tool clears areas that are already cleared (bare land) #9061
Comments
Intended behaviour I feel. You can bulldoze bulldozed land. Your counter-example of tree is kind of wrong, as you can plant more trees on top of existing trees (up to 3), and it does cost money. Landscaping that doesn't alter the land height doesn't get included because it doesn't do anything. |
Additionally, clearing empty land (grassland) is in fact an action, and it is done internally as part of building most things, like building rails on a tile actually clears the tile first, then places the rail. You will see a difference in cost of building rail on a "grass" tile versus a "dirt" tile, since the "dirt" tile is already clear. |
I think the verdict is that this is not a bug. Sorry :( We consider the bulldozing an action, no matter if the land was just bulldozed. As mentioned above, there are reasons for that, but bulldozed land is also very quickly not fully bare anymore. Basically, the action is to ask bulldozers to run over the land, no matter how it looks. Which costs money / terraform costs. And indeed, if you play with very low terraform limits, that does mean that if you want to bulldoze a large area, you will have to make a lot of smaller clicks. But I am afraid that is what the game is. |
smth like #7497 would probably work well for this usecase |
Version of OpenTTD
1.11.1
Expected result
When clearing an area of tiles, the clear action should ignore any tiles that are already cleared (bare land, appearing as brown dirt). Any tiles that are not fully bare land (such as any stage of grass, snow or desert) still get cleared as normal.
Actual result
When clearing an area of tiles, the clear action will clear tiles that are already cleared (bare land), which, when combined with very low landscaping limits, means that you have to select lots of very small areas, increasing the complexity and number of unique clicks you have to do to clear a large area. By contrast, planting trees and terraforming can be performed gradually just be selecting the same large area over and over again, even on very low landscaping limits.
Steps to reproduce
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: