linux_zen: 5.10.1 -> 5.10.5 #108688
linux_zen: 5.10.1 -> 5.10.5 #108688
Conversation
|
Hi! I'm an experimental bot. My goal is to guide this PR through its stages, hopefully ending with a merge. You can read up on the usage here. |
|
/status needs_merger |
|
Have you verified that the packages that failed to build in the |
|
They all sound like modules that also fail on vanilla 5.10 and many failed on 5.9 too. |
|
I compared the lists and these modules are not in the list of current
Could you double-check if they built before the update? |
|
Those are proprietary modules and that's why they don't show up in the hydra build failures, it doesn't even attempt to build them. amdgpu-pro is only compatible with one kernel version, the legacy nvidia drivers are even less compatible than their newest shiny BLOB of crap and the other two I wouldn't expect to be compatible with any reasonably up-to-date kernel. A quick check confirmed that just now. Broken modules are simple not being marked as such when a new ABI-incompatible kernel version is added to Nixpkgs. We didn't even have the infrastructure to support doing that until very recently and I'm not sure whether that has been forward-ported from 20.09 yet. Most of these have been broken for as long as the zen kernel has been in Nixpkgs, that's why I didn't even bother investigating these "failures". The zen kernel is also fairly vanilla and, if anything, it'd support more modules than the mainline kernel. |
|
@timokau All 5 of those fail to build on 5.10.1 for me: |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Diff LGTM. I ran nixpkgs-review on the bump to 5.10.1 as well, and all the same packages are broken / failed to build (except hyperv-daemons was fixed, it looks like).
Result of nixpkgs-review pr 108688 run on x86_64-linux 1
8 packages marked as broken and skipped:
- linuxPackages_zen.ixgbevf
- linuxPackages_zen.lttng-modules
- linuxPackages_zen.ndiswrapper
- linuxPackages_zen.nvidia_x11_legacy304
- linuxPackages_zen.phc-intel
- linuxPackages_zen.rtl8723bs
- linuxPackages_zen.sch_cake
- linuxPackages_zen.tbs
22 packages failed to build:
- linuxPackages_zen.akvcam
- linuxPackages_zen.amdgpu-pro
- linuxPackages_zen.anbox
- linuxPackages_zen.chipsec
- linuxPackages_zen.cryptodev
- linuxPackages_zen.dpdk
- linuxPackages_zen.ena
- linuxPackages_zen.mwprocapture
- linuxPackages_zen.mxu11x0
- linuxPackages_zen.nvidia_x11_legacy340
- linuxPackages_zen.nvidia_x11_legacy390
- linuxPackages_zen.oci-seccomp-bpf-hook
- linuxPackages_zen.rtl8192eu
- linuxPackages_zen.rtl8812au
- linuxPackages_zen.rtl8814au
- linuxPackages_zen.rtl8821au
- linuxPackages_zen.rtl8821ce
- linuxPackages_zen.rtl88x2bu
- linuxPackages_zen.rtl88xxau-aircrack
- linuxPackages_zen.rtlwifi_new
- linuxPackages_zen.virtualbox
- linuxPackages_zen.virtualboxGuestAdditions
51 packages built:
- linuxPackages_zen.acpi_call
- linuxPackages_zen.asus-wmi-sensors
- linuxPackages_zen.batman_adv
- linuxPackages_zen.bbswitch
- linuxPackages_zen.bcc
- linuxPackages_zen.bpftrace
- linuxPackages_zen.broadcom_sta
- linuxPackages_zen.can-isotp
- linuxPackages_zen.cpupower
- linuxPackages_zen.ddcci-driver
- linuxPackages_zen.digimend
- linuxPackages_zen.evdi
- linuxPackages_zen.facetimehd
- linuxPackages_zen.fwts-efi-runtime
- linuxPackages_zen.gcadapter-oc-kmod
- linuxPackages_zen.hyperv-daemons
- linuxPackages_zen.intel-speed-select
- linuxPackages_zen.it87
- linuxPackages_zen.jool
- linux_zen (linuxPackages_zen.kernel)
- linuxPackages_zen.mba6x_bl
- linuxPackages_zen.netatop
- linuxPackages_zen.nvidia_x11
- linuxPackages_zen.nvidia_x11_beta
- linuxPackages_zen.nvidia_x11_vulkan_beta
- linuxPackages_zen.nvidiabl
- linuxPackages_zen.openafs (linuxPackages_zen.openafs_1_8)
- linuxPackages_zen.openafs_1_9
- linuxPackages_zen.openrazer
- linuxPackages_zen.perf
- linuxPackages_zen.ply
- linuxPackages_zen.r8125
- linuxPackages_zen.r8168
- linuxPackages_zen.rtl8821cu
- linuxPackages_zen.sysdig
- linuxPackages_zen.system76
- linuxPackages_zen.system76-acpi
- linuxPackages_zen.system76-io
- linuxPackages_zen.systemtap
- linuxPackages_zen.tmon
- linuxPackages_zen.tp_smapi
- linuxPackages_zen.turbostat
- linuxPackages_zen.tuxedo-keyboard
- linuxPackages_zen.usbip
- linuxPackages_zen.v4l2loopback
- linuxPackages_zen.v86d
- linuxPackages_zen.vhba
- linuxPackages_zen.x86_energy_perf_policy
- linuxPackages_zen.xpadneo
- linuxPackages_zen.zenpower
- linuxPackages_zen.zfs (linuxPackages_zen.zfsStable ,linuxPackages_zen.zfsUnstable)
|
I see that this has already been resolved in #108958. Thank you for the explanations and for keeping the package up to date. It would be nice to mark those modules as broken for incompatible kernel versions, but I agree that is out of scope for this PR. |
Motivation for this change
Closes #108239
Things done
sandboxinnix.confon non-NixOS linux)nix-shell -p nixpkgs-review --run "nixpkgs-review wip"./result/bin/)nix path-info -Sbefore and after)/marvin opt-in
/status needs_reviewer
Result of
nixpkgs-reviewrun on x86_64-linux 18 packages marked as broken and skipped:
23 packages failed to build:
51 packages built: